Is India ready for a complete transition to organic agriculture?

The organic food movement in India is gaining traction, driven by increased health consciousness and lifestyle shifts among urban consumers. As of 2023, around 2.6 million hectares of land are dedicated to organic farming, with over 4.43 million farmers involved, making India a leading global producer of organic food. The organic product market has reached approximately US$ 1.5 billion, though challenges like lower yields and mislabeling persist.

Transitioning fully to organic methods faces hurdles, particularly regarding productivity and conversion costs, especially as India’s population is expected to reach 1.6 billion by 2030. However, successful examples from states like Sikkim and Rajasthan demonstrate the viability of organic farming, supported by community participation and government initiatives. As urban consumers increasingly choose organic products, this trend signifies a transformative movement that enhances farmers’ livelihoods and promotes environmental sustainability within India’s agricultural framework

OrganicImage source: Shutterstock

The organic food movement in India has witnessed a significant surge in popularity among urban consumers, fundamentally reshaping the dynamics of the food and beverage sector. This article explores the motivations fuelling this shift towards gourmet and organic options—primarily the growing health consciousness and lifestyle changes among the urban populace—while examining its implications for local agriculture, farmers, and the economy at large.

Overview of the Organic Food Farming Scenario

Organic food farming in India is experiencing significant growth, driven by rising consumer demand for healthier and more sustainable food options. As of 2023, approximately 2.6 million hectares of farmland was dedicated to organic cultivation, accounting for about 1.5% of the total agricultural land in the country. India currently possesses the highest number of organic producers worldwide, with over 4.43 million organic farmers.

The organic area under cultivation has expanded dramatically, with the government reporting that about 5.91 million hectares of land are now dedicated to organic farming (as of 2022-23), reflecting a significant push towards sustainable agricultural practices. 

Despite the promising growth, challenges persist. Organic farming typically yields about 14% to 18% lower compared to conventional farming due to its nature of excluding synthetic fertilizers and pesticides. Additionally, the lack of widespread awareness and infrastructure for organic practices hinders its full potential.

Income Sources for Farmers

The organic food market in India has reached a value of US$ 1.51 billion. in 2023, with projections of growing at a CAGR of approximately 22%, reaching a projected value of US$ 9.04 billion by 2032. This increasing demand for organic products is resoundingly seen in urban areas, where consumers have a heightened focus on quality and safe consumption.

A Nielsen survey recorded that 72% of Indian consumers were willing to pay a premium for organic products, reflecting a strong trust in the health benefits they offer and indicating a strong uptick in market growth. Organic farming can provide farmers with sustainable income through various channels. Research indicates that organic farmers can earn higher prices for their produce due to consumer willingness to pay a premium for organic products. 

According to recent studies by the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR), the average increase in net income for organic farmers can be estimated at around 4.6% per year, indicating significant financial benefits compared to conventional farming under favorable market conditions.

Can India go completely organic?

Transitioning to a fully organic farming system in India poses significant challenges. The challenges include persistently lower yields, increased labor intensity, and high conversion costs. Reports suggest that yields in organic farming could increase over time but often start off lower due to the initial adoption phase, which may take 2-3 years before soil health improves sufficiently.

According to an economic survey, while organic farmers incur lower costs (14–19% less than conventional farmers), the primary concern arises from the lower productivity. With India’s population projected to reach 1.6 billion by 2030, completely shifting to organic could strain the food supply unless alternative solutions are efficiently implemented. 

However, several success stories highlight the potential of organic farming in India. Sikkim stands out as the first 100% organic state in the world to achieve full organic certification in 2016, with a strong emphasis on government support and community involvement. The state reported a doubling of farmers’ incomes, illustrating organic farming’s economic viability and potential to fulfill local food demands.

Similarly, Rajasthan has about 60,000 hectares under organic farming, with 97.3% of farmers agreeing to adopt the method due to awareness of health benefits. Each case demonstrates that while challenges exist, viable pathways toward increasing organic acreage are achievable through community, government engagement, and market demand.

Despite the positive narrative surrounding organic farming, the sector grapples with significant concerns of fraud and mislabeling. Instances of mislabeling conventional produce as organic pose severe risks to both consumer trust and the industry’s reputation. Fraudulent practices, such as false certification and selling non-organic goods as organic, emphasize the need for improved regulatory frameworks and stringent oversight to protect consumers and uphold the integrity of the organic label.

According to Bharathwaj Sridhar, sustainability consultant, “the certification process for organic farming is quite arduous and can be tedious. It typically takes about three years to obtain the necessary certification, which is a significant commitment for farmers. Moreover, the challenge lies not just in one’s own farm practices, but also in ensuring that neighboring farms do not utilize fertilizers that could contaminate your organic crops. This requirement adds another layer of difficulty and concern for those looking to transition to organic farming. Therefore, while the intention to go organic is commendable, the practical hurdles involved cannot be overlooked.”

Methods of Organic Farming

The emphasis on sustainable methods not only enhances soil health and biodiversity but also fosters community development through shared knowledge of organic practices. The transition to organic farming relies on sustainable methods that emphasize soil health, biodiversity, and ecological balance. Key techniques include:

  • Crop Rotation: A fundamental practice that helps prevent soil depletion and manages pests naturally.
  • Use of Green Manures: Farmers often plant cover crops that enhance soil fertility and structure.
  • Composting: Organic waste is converted into nutrient-rich compost, reducing reliance on synthetic fertilizers.
  • Biological Pest Control: Utilizing natural predators to manage pest populations instead of chemical pesticides.
  • Vermiculture: Employing earthworms to enhance soil health and nutrient availability.

A holistic approach focusing on self-sustaining agricultural systems, emphasizing organic inputs available on farms. These practices not only improve soil health but also promote sustainability, thereby benefiting both farming communities and consumers.

Call to Action

​The organic food trend in India signifies a transformative movement that enhances not only the health of consumers but also the livelihoods of farmers and the environment.​ As more urban consumers embrace organic options, it fosters a deeper connection between the community and sustainable agriculture, creating a holistic approach to food production. This growing awareness and commitment to organic practices can lead to a more sustainable future for India’s agricultural sector and its economy.

“​India would not be able to go completely organic due to several challenges.​ The sense is that the productivity in organic production is much lower than that of conventional production. It’s not even reaching 80% of conventional levels. As of today, we are definitely not self-sustainable with our agricultural production. We find ourselves importing a significant amount of agricultural commodities while also exporting them. The import-export data clearly reflects that we are importing more agricultural commodities than we are exporting, highlighting the pressing challenges we face in achieving agricultural self-sufficiency,” Sridhar further adds. 

While a complete transition to organic farming faces several challenges—lower yields, regulatory fraud, and economic feasibility—the potential benefits for farmers and ecosystems remain significant. Employing effective organic practices and addressing current challenges through policy and community support will be essential in reshaping India’s agricultural landscape for generations to come.

Leave a comment

Subscribe To Newsletter

Stay ahead in the dynamic world of trade and commerce with India Business & Trade's weekly newsletter.